How we rate the evidence

Not every study method has the same research behind it. Each guide carries one of three labels.

Strong evidence

Supported by many studies, in different groups and settings, with fairly consistent results.

Guides with this label:

Moderate or mixed evidence

Some good research supports it, but results vary or depend on the situation.

Guides with this label:

Limited evidence

Popular, but with little or inconsistent research support. Treat as an experiment, not a proven method.

Guides with this label:

How we decide

  1. We look for reviews and meta-analyses in educational and cognitive psychology, and for the original studies behind them.
  2. We check whether results hold across different students, subjects and settings, not only in one lab task.
  3. We note who was studied. Results from college students may not apply to young children, and the reverse is also true.
  4. We separate "the method works in a study" from "the method will work for you." A good average result does not guarantee a good personal result.
  5. When research is thin, mixed or missing, we say so and use the limited label, even if the method is very popular.

Why "limited" does not mean "useless"

A limited label means we cannot point to solid research. Some of these methods may still help certain students, often because they get them to start or to review. If you use one, treat it as an experiment: try it for a couple of weeks and check whether you remember more.

Things to keep in mind

Browse all guides